So here is the update, I don't think it was the older version. I got it to work sometimes. I don't know why it worked, but here is what I did. I would have to launch ME1 with FBX running, several times. It would often take multiple launches before the interface would appear in the game. Once it showed up, the game recorded fine. I would record some game play, stop it after a little bit and then the interface would reappear after the video was saved like it should, most of the time. There were times that it wouldn't appear again (I have no idea what caused this) and I would just have to relaunch the game to get it back. It took me longer to get through the game because I recorded my entire playthrough, but I managed to do it. If I do another playthrough in the future I probably will avoid capturing it. Once I hit ME2 and ME3 FBX worked great. I am now working with Dragon Age: Origins, other than the game getting really slow after playing for a bit, it's working great too.